Sunday, February 12, 2012

Skidelsky on Keynes and Hayek Similarities

Only Two Schools of Thought to Model Crises & Slumps
Sets apart from Classical & Neoclassical schools

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yzQgnNOwJoo

Professor Lord Robert Skidelsky, member of the House of Lords, and the one of the UK's preeminent Keynesian economists discusses similarities between Hayek's and Keynes' schools of thought. In this 20 minute clip, Skidelsky explains that during an economic crisis, the Keynesian and Hayekian (Austrian) schools of thought are the points of view which matter most. This is because these are the two most prominent schools of thought which recognize that markets fail and that crises form with some regularity. Aside from predicting that economic and financial crises occur, both school of thought make the attempt to explain how this process occurs.

Under Hayek, it is mal-investment which leads destruction of the capital stock, and ultimately to crisis. Under Keynes meanwhile, elaborated on the effects of uncertainty and volatility, and drops in demand leading to economic contraction. With Classical and Neoclassical schools on the other hand, these events -ARE NOT- predicted to occur. Rather, the assumptions are that all markets clear and that all markets are efficient. Any deviations from this outcome are strictly due to exceptional circumstances and are not really part of the model. Obviously, during a crisis, it does us no good to assume that crises do not occur, except for exceptional circumstances. 

Although the Keynesian and Austrian schools of thought come up with different explanations, and hence different policy solutions, it can be said that both schools of thought have crisis resolution at the center of their intellectual traditions. Furthermore, both schools of thought cite the dislocation and mis-allocation of savings and investment as central to an economic crisis. As such, both schools of thought should be considered to have at least a kernel of useful analysis during and economic crisis. Moreover, the analysis and lessons of both should be considered during times of economic crisis and slump. 


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About the Speaker:

Robert Alexander, Barron of Skidelsky is an emeritus professor of economics at Warwick and a member of the House of Lords in the UK. He was elected a Fellow of the British Academy in 1994 and has published an award-winning three-volume biography on J.M. Keynes. 

Sunday, February 5, 2012

WSJ: EU May Back Away from Basel

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203920204577197032914479416.html

Regulators Under Pressure from Lobbyists 
On February 2nd, the Wall Street Journal reported that European regulators are considering loosening rules on Capital Requirements. EU Policy makers and regulators are weighing whether to permit banks to hold a broader variety of assets to meet new safety standards. Because the current rules are the product of G20 negotiations and have been implemented across the OECD, relaxation of the rules is likely to spark a fight with policy makers across the world. 

As if we learned absolutely nothing from 2008, EU regulators are considering allowing “Asset-backed instruments [ABS] of high liquid and credit quality”. In other words, banks will be allowed to have "AAA-rated" Mortgage-Back Securities instead of actual safe assets in order to meet their capital requirements. 

This is ostensibly being done as a short cut to make it easier for banks meet core capital requirements. Because one aspect of the current recovery period is marked by the reluctance of banks across the OECD to engage in new lending of any kind, such a step might encourage banks to start lending again. If only things were so simple. While restarting lending is critical to economic recovery, we should not be so naive as to do this by feeding the underlying cause of the crisis. Certainly, the Vienna Agreement whereby bankers from across Europe were encouraged not to pull out of Eastern Europe, where the primary bank activity consists of private lending and project finance demonstrated the importance of the role of lending. 

In this spirit, it may be a good idea to try to think outside the box. While we need to restart lending in productive areas of the economy, we also need to ensure that bank capital is as solid as possible. In other words we need to leave the capital rules as they have been established, and engage in lending by alternate means. 

What Would Hayek Say?
To state is plainly, von Hayek believed that mal-investments wreck the economy. According to the Austrian school what we really need to be concerned about is care-less investments which do not yield what they should and do not add to productivity. This is how economics slumps are born, and they start out as bubbles. This sort of relaxation of financial rules would lead to exactly the type of mal-investment Hayek and the Austrians were talking about.

What Keynes Would Say
As Skidelky has noted, Keynes was a proponent of directly addressing the sources of economic troubles. generally, he was a proponent of using the influence of the state as an alternate means of distribution in both the fiscal and the monetary sense. 

German Historical School Would Say...
The doctrine of Historical School is established (as the name states) based on a study of economic history. To that effect:

1: ABSs under questionable AAA rating being used as Basel II capital was at the core of the 2008 financial collapse. Letting ABS be considered as capital yet again cannot lead to anything good.

2: More generally, we should examine post-crisis economic recovery periods which came after the collapse of the bubble. While it is true that employment and economic growth lag for as much as a decade after the collapse, stable economic recovery has only been possible under the auspices of smart regulation which addressed the underlying causes of economic stability. Its as true for the tulip bubble as it is in 2012. 

What We Need 
Simply stated, the capital rules and financial regulations established by the G20 and the Basel III rules need to stay in place if we are to have a stable recovery built on the recovery of real, tangible economic output. While the process may be slowed by bank lending reluctance due to the new capital requirements, we can use alternate means to distribute lending to the productive real economy. For example, project finance and real estate lending could be distributed by municipal authorities under central bank auspices. This would restart lending and reduce some of the need for radically expansive monetary growth in one bold stroke.


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About the Author:
Max Berre is an economist at the EDHEC-Risk Institute who has worked as a sovereign debt expert at the Inter-American Development Bank in Washington and has taught financial economics at Maastricht University in the Netherlands. 

Thursday, February 2, 2012

Software Patents vs Competitiveness: Less is More

Less is More 

http://www.dit.upm.es/~joaquin/report_en.pdf   (Madrid-based EU Study)
http://www.researchoninnovation.org/swpat.pdf  (Boston Law + Federal Reserve Study)

A pair of studies on the effect of software patents on innovation and competition in the marketplace. Both studies take a negative view on the effect of software patents. 

Fundamentally, this should come as no surprise to economists. While the pro-intellectual property rights side of the argument sees intellectual property rights as being equivalent to all other property rights (tangibility and duplicability characteristics notwithstanding) and consists mostly of legal professionals and law scholars, economists see it differently. What economists see in this debate are market-distorting monopolies. Everyone who ever took a first-year economics course is trained to think that monopolies cause inefficiency and should be avoided, or at least limited as much as possible. In the case of the IPR debate, a rat by any other name, still smells as strong. 

Lately however, legal scholars in the EU have begun to see the IP issue in the same skeptical light that most economists see it in. This is due largely to the role that patents have in emerging anti-competitive behavior in the I.T. industry. The list of emerging anti-competitive crimes includes frivolous patents, patent trolling, use of patents as competitive-entry barriers, and patent-based M&A. While many of these actions are not yet illegal in most first-world countries, the growing chorus of voices on this issue in both the EU and Switzerland may soon change that. 

Madrid-Based EU Study
This study finds that software patents have the effect of reducing competition, encouraging obvious and frivolous patents, fostering the emergence of artificial entry barriers, and the replacement of both education and R&D-based competition with litigation-based competition and patent-portfolio-based competition  (patent trolling). The study also finds that software patents favor a smaller number of large, rigid companies (oligopolistic firms), who channel resources into claiming patents rather than R&D. In short, the growth of software patents has been harmful to the software industry in general and to the European software industry in particular. 

Boston Law and Federal Reserve Study
On the other side of the Atlantic, an empirical look at the effects of software patents in the US in the wake of recent legal changes. Whereas during the 1970s, federal court decisions typically described computer programs as mathematical algorithms, which are unpatentable subject matter under U.S. law, court decisions in the 1980s and 1990s lowered the standards, allowing software to be patentable. 

The study finds a disconnect between software patent propensity of software patents and R&D investments or productivity growth.  Furthermore, the study finds that software patent acquisition acts as a substitute for firm-level R&D. In short, legal changes in the US software patent system has failed to incentivize R&D in the software sector, as classical theory has established. Rather, legal changes encouraged more strategic patenting and less innovation.

What Do We Need?
Essentially, IPR and patent law needs to be reformed in order to curtail anti-competitive activity. In the future, it is likely that competition law will evolve to the point that patent trolling will be as illegal as collusion, price fixing, and other monopolistic behavior.

While there are many directions in which reform can go, the moderate course is one of simply watering-down existing IPR law in order to limit anti-competititive behavior. In the future, it is likely that there will be limits on what  can be patented. The list should include obvious technology, traditional technology/medicine, life forms, genomes, and algorithms (all of which can currently be patented in the US). Furthermore, in order to increase competition, the protections granted by patents should be continually reduced, thereby stopping patent-holders from resting on their laurels. Lastly, IPR infringement lawsuits should be subjected to stricter burdens of proof. This measure could discourage patent-trolling in a big way.

http://www.dit.upm.es/~joaquin/report_en.pdf    (Madrid-based EU Study)
http://www.researchoninnovation.org/swpat.pdf  (Boston Law + Federal Reserve Study)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Sunday, January 29, 2012

Le Monde: European Austerity Deemed Ineffective


Both Rationale and Effectiveness Put in Doubt
A January 2012  article printed in Le Monde deems austerity to be ineffective. While German Chancellor Angela Merkel has presented the current budgetary arrangements as a way to emerge from the crisis, many voices across Europe are starting to loudly disagree. 

Among other sources, the article quotes American economist Joseph Stiglitz on the matter. "The adjustment policies in the U.S. and Europe will not solve the economic crisis. The budget deficit is not responsible for the crisis, on the contrary, the crisis that has caused the budget deficit." This was said by Stiglitz at an economics conference in Argentina last month. 

While it's true that placing blame more accurately does not necessarily lead to an effective solution, a correct view of the situation does help put the current economic situation into perspective. 

The article also quotes Andrew Grjebine, the director of the Sciences-Po Centre d'Etudes et des Recherches Internationales (CERI-Sciences-Po), who called a European recovery based solely on the pillar austerity both unsustainable and flat out destructive. The key, Grjebine says is not to reduce the level of growth in order to pay down the debt. That simply leads to a viscous circle which is difficult to emerge from. This is especially so in the case of countries who currently need strong economic growth, such as Spain and Portugal.  

Along the same lines, in his recent NY times op-ed US economist Paul Krugman recommends simply trying to outgrow the debt by employing how growth policies in order to ensure that the GDP grows faster than the debt. 

Another truth which may ultimately emerge is that the international attempt to force austerity on countries who already have desperate economic situations will simply lead to mass protests and possibly even widespread violence. Let us not forget that the fall of Ben Ali began as a protest against unemployment.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About the Author:
Max Berre is an economist who has worked as a sovereign debt expert at the Inter-American Development Bank in Washington and has taught financial economics at Maastricht University in the Netherlands. 

Sunday, January 22, 2012

Swiss Senate: NO to Strict Intellectual Property Law

Senate Report: Leave Swiss Copyright Laws Alone
http://www.ejpd.admin.ch/content/dam/data/pressemitteilung/2011/2011-11-30/ber-br-f.pdf

A 2011 Swiss Senate study on the effect of downloading and file-sharing recommends maintaining current Swiss intellectual property laws. Under the current law, downloading is legal.  The study, undertaken by the Swiss Federal Department of Justice and Police, concluded that the overall effect of downloading on consumer behavior is to change consumption patterns away from albums and DVD purchases 

The Underlying Economics
The study finds no negative impact on cultural and intellectual creation. In fact, a 2009 study carried out in the UK found the effects of file-sharing to be that of an increase of revenues to creators of art and intellectual property, as well as a reduction of revenue to the record labels.

http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/technology/shanerichmond/100004204/the-graph-the-record-industry-doesnt-want-you-to-see/ 

According Swedish MEP Christian Engström, this should come as no surprise. While the core economic function of the artists is to create artistic, that of record labels is to distribute said content. Because file-sharing is a more efficient distribution method for artistic content, it should come as no surprise that the distribution industry would begin to decline, along Shumpeterian lines. This is a concept which many economists feel simply cannot be effectively legislated against, certainly not without doing more harm than good.  

SOPA and the Role of Intellectual property
The concept of intellectual property rights can be seen as an umbrella concept for several different rights. On one hand, there is the right to take credit for creation of the intellectual work or product. Then, there is the right to claim a commercial monopoly on duplication of the product or work, for profit.

Lastly and most controversial, there is the right a monopoly on performance or expression of the intellectual product. -and to prevent others from doing so- The last one has proven controversial because it essentially means that the dissemination and the viral spread of culture and research must be slowed down, in order that financial profit accumulates to the party holding the monopoly right. 

All else aside, intellectual property rights are monopoly rights and their debate should be treated as such. They exist ostensibly on a temporary basis and meant to serve as an incentive for intellectual creativity. While many economists are deeply suspicious of any argument for a monopoly, most are willing to put up with a limited amount of necessary evil of distortion of the market-place in order to incentivize R&D. What most economists are suspicious of is the expansion of such distortion, where it already exists.  

SOPA is a highly controversial bill which entered the the House of Representatives in February 2012. The bill ostensibly sought to defend the intellectual property rights for holders of copyrighted material, at the expense of individual freedom of communication on the internet. No surprisingly, the bill was mostly backed by the distribution industry, who at present time makes the majority of the revenue from the copyrighted content. Their stake is under threat from efficient competition. Their defense is to use hostile language about theft and piracy as a shallow attempt to frame the debate as anything but a debate about monopoly power or a competition between distribution systems. 

This debate should be seen for what it is. This is an attempt by special interests to seek the artificial creation and expansion of a monopoly, at the expense of both freedom and creative output. The public doesn't need this and the artists don't need it either. The word "piracy" is mere smoke screen.


The Senate Study
The Senate report report provides an overview of the current situation. Up to one third of those over 15 years in Switzerland downloading free music, movies and games. Nevertheless, the share of disposable income spent by consumers and consumers in this area remains stable. Thus, users and users sharing sites continue to spend on the entertainment industry. The overall effect of downloading is that expenditures on CD and DVDs are being displace by increased expenditures on merchandise, movie tickets, and concert tickets. Total entertainment expenditure has remained roughly the same according to the report.

http://www.ejpd.admin.ch/content/dam/data/pressemitteilung/2011/2011-11-30/ber-br-f.pdf (FR)
http://www.ejpd.admin.ch/content/dam/data/pressemitteilung/2011/2011-11-30/ber-br-d.pdf (DE)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Swiss Conseil Fédéral is the upper chamber of the Swiss Legislature. It serves as both the main federal body and the Swiss Head of State. It has seven members, each representing one canton and heading one of the seven federal executive departments.   

Thursday, January 19, 2012

PES: European Ratings Illegitimate

European Socialists Dismiss Rating Agencies
"A dozen anonymous analysts with no shred of legitimacy and a proven track record of gross inefficiency, effectively decided on Friday to make life much harder for millions of Europeans" declaed Sergei Stanishev, president of the Party of European Socialists (PES). "This is an international scam that has to stop."

Recent events have seen ratings agencies issue downgrades to 16 of the 17 Eurozone members, including Germany and France, in addition to a downgrade of the European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF), ostensibly because last Friday's downgrade of France and Austria mean that there were now insufficient AAA-rated guarantors for the efsf to have the top-rating, risk-pooling possibilities aside.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-16586807


Effects of a Ratings Downgrade
The de-facto effect of a ratings downgrade amounts to increased borrowing costs. This happens via loss of investor demand for the debt instrument in question.In fact, since institutional investors  are obliged specific risk/return characteristics to meet their fiduciary stndards and banks are obliged to specific capital requirements to counterbalance their positions just to meet the Basel rules, the process is fairly automated.

In the case of a sovereign ratings downgrade, it means that a country's government -as well as the citizens and taxpayers- face increased borrowing costs. This can make a huge difference when it comes to hard budgetary line-items such as healthcare, education, and national defense. This is the reason that the recent behavior of ratings agencies with regards to the EU and its member naionts has been an issue of such serious concern. What's worse, is that corporate debt from a country is ALWAYS rated less safe than sovereign debt, meaning that there are secondary effects in the private debt markets. 


Is it Legit?
Principly, the concern is that these higher costs are being imposed due largely to political bias on the part of the rating agencies and associated parties. In fact, during the 1990s, it emerged that right-wing Canadian sources were attempting to pressure Moody's ratings analysts to downgrade Canadian sovereign debt. This was ultimately done in order to help find a justification for the Liberal party's budget slashing agenda in 1993. 


A further point to consider, is the role of CRAs during the sub-prime mortage derivate story in the mid-2000s. At that time, rating agencies were handing out AAA ratings to issues of junk-debt. In exchange, the three main ratings agencies made massive revenues, as the issuing partie who paid the ratings agencies compensated well for free AAA ratings. Officially, it was all disguised as "consulting fees". Since this behavior came to light, leading to an explicit ban on such practices in the US in the 2009 Dodd-Frank Act, the ratings agencies have been looking for opportunities to send the message that they have stopped given away high ratings and intend for their ratings to actually be taken seriously. What better target than sovereign debt then. After all, states DO NOT pay for the services of the rating agencies, so there so is no incentive to give away ratings. 


EU Legislative Efforts
The European Parliament is currently examining proposals for more effective regulation of CRAs and the PES intends to announce a major campaign to regulate the CRA issue next week.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Saturday, January 14, 2012

The EU Financial Volatility Tax


The European Financial Transaction Tax (FTT) has gained traction within the European Union. Last fall, the measure won support in both European Commission and the European Parliament. The legislation was argued in the Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee, where it won support from MEPs from a wide plethora of parties. Despite passing the parliament, the FTT has gotten bogged down in the European Council. The purposes of the financial transaction tax are two-fold:

1: Financial Market Stability
A small financial transaction tax serves to moderate volatility in the financial markets. Because the size of the tax should be very small –pennies per share– the amount of the tax becomes negligible to the small investor. This is especially true for the smallest investors, who face large brokerage fees far outweighing  the proposed tax, and for whom brokers might even leave transactions costs un-altered. Institutional investors such as pension funds and oil fund, whose main wealth management strategies focus on shareholder activism, as well as long-term buy-and hold strategies, will also barely be affected. Passively managed portfolios will also remain virtually unaffected.

Hedge funds, large speculators, and other highly-leveraged players meanwhile, would be more seriously affected by this measure due to the size and frequency to which they change their financial positions. While these are parties the main contributors to volatility, their contribution to growth is somewhat questionable compared to more conservative investors. The slowing of their speculator activity is projected to contribute a great deal of overall stability in the market.

The proposed legislation, supported by S&D, the European Parliament’s Social-Democrat alliance aims to set the tax rate at 0.05% of the transaction.

2: Revenue
Given the sheer amount of financial transactions, even a somewhat reduced financial transaction volume would give rise to massive revenues. A further positive aspect of FTT revenues is their progressive nature, given that the burden of this tax would fall mainly on the wealthy and on wealthiest players in the financial industry. Given that we are in a period which is known for sovereign debt uncertainties, this might serve to alleviate budgetary problems across the OECD.

Nevertheless, the revenue-gathering effectiveness of this tax is a somewhat complex matter, and there are administrative challenges. In 2011, the IMF conducted a study on the administrative feasibility of the FTT. It concluded that while exchange-traded financial instruments can be taxed relatively easily, there lies some difficulty in the taxation of OTC products and derivatives, leading to some level of product substitution. Nevertheless, the study finds that these difficulties are not wholly insurmountable. Revenue maximization however should only be seen as a secondary objective of the FTT, after stability has been financial market stability taken into consideration.

Austrian WIFO Study on FTT Feasibility
The Austrian Institute for Economic Research (WIFO), a Vienna-based think-tank has undertaken a feasibility study on the FTT. It asks whether the volume of transaction is sufficiently large to justify such a tax. It also examines the effect on speculators versus the effect on real investment.

The study finds a remarkable discrepancy between the levels of financial transactions and the levels of the "underlying" transactions in the "real world". The volume of currency transactions is found to be nearly 70 times larger than trade of goods and services. Moreover, the transaction volume of interest rate securities is even several hundred times greater than overall investment. Moreover, said discrepancy has increased dramatically since the 1990s.

IMF Study on FTT
Last year, the IMF published two studies on the feasibility of the FTT. In Brondolo 2011, the administrative feasibility of the FTT is analyzed by the IMF. It examines the various ways in which an FTT could be structured, as well as the possible obstacles.

While financial product substitution may become an issue and OTC markets are somewhat more difficult to tax, the FTT can nevertheless be feasibly instituted in a coherent fashion.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About the Authors:
The Austrian Institute for Economic Research – WIFO was founded by Friedrich August von Hayek and Ludwig von Mises in 1927. Its brief is to analyse economic developments in Austria and internationally, thereby contributing to the establishment of a sound basis for economic policy and entrepreneurial decision-making.

The IMF is an organization of 187 countries, working to foster global monetary cooperation, secure financial stability, facilitate international trade, promote high employment and sustainable economic growth, and reduce poverty around the world.