Saturday, March 10, 2012

ALMP: The Path to Less Unemployment

- This piece is dedicated to my American readership. Presented here are the sorts of thing I came to Europe to learn about - 
http://www.tinbergen.nl/cost/london/kluve.pdf

Because unemployment levels have been in the news on both sides of the Atlantic since the crisis began, a lot has been said on what to do about it. This is the case on both ends of the political spectrum. Unfortunately, unemployment is used as a justification by right-wing politicians in all countries to do some pretty nasty policies which have the final effect of redistributing wealth upwards to the richest few percent of the population. Basically, those of us who live in the 99% should be worried that we are constantly about to be made worse-off by spending-cuts, tax-cuts, wage cuts to "restore competitivity" and legalized union busting.

What we need are policies designed to actually make the labor force more competitive and productive, keeping people on the job as much as possible. The importance of keeping people in the job cannot be stressed enough. As if the link to consumer spending were not a convincing reason to try to maintain high employment figures (there are plenty who actually think consumer spending of of secondary importance in an economy), there is also the question of  productivity. While, productivity is influenced by how long you have been doing the job, periods of unemployment not only keep productivity from improving, but actually decrease it as well. Put formally:

Marginal Productivity of Labor = F(years of education) + F(years of experience)

In other words, if we aren't targeting one of these two areas, we probably aren't improving productivity.

What are ALMPs?
Active Labor Market Policies are pro-active, pro-worker policies designed to reduce unemployment by improving the productivity of the labor force through either education or job experience.

Examples of ALMPs packages generally include:
  • Job search Assistance: This reduces frictional unemployment.
  • Life-Long Learning: Specialized labor market training can take both low-skilled forms such as basic computer-literacy courses, as well as high-skilled forms such as foreign language training and sector-specific skill-certification.
  • Wage Subsidies to the Private Sector: Under this sort of scheme, part of the employee's wage is paid by the state, making him less expensive to the employer. Such a policy should be used on a temporary and graduated basis in order to discourage employer dependency on such policies. 
  • Direct Job Creation in the Public Sector: One of the primary uses of State-Owned Enterprises is to do counter-cyclical policy. For those who think that public-sector job-creation leads to inefficiency, just remember that when we are comparing this policy to persistent unemployment and idle, un-utilized resources, almost any level of output is more productive, especially in the long-term.
Costs
According to the OECD, even the most expensive and most extensive ALMP programs cost less than 1.8% of GDP. In exchange for this miniscule expenditure, the employment effect in the countries on the far left of the graph simply cannot be overlstated.


The RWI / IZA Study
This study, undertaken by the German Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA) is a meta-study, which was meant to study what worked and what didn't across the EU-15 in the early 2000's.
Abstract
Measures of Active Labor Market Policy are widely used in European countries, but despite many econometric evaluation studies no conclusive cross-country evidence exists regarding "what program works for what target group under what (economic and institutional) circumstances?". This paper results from an extensive research project for the European Commission aimed at answering that question using a meta-analytical framework. The empirical results are surprisingly clear-cut: Rather than contextual factors such as labor market institutions or the business cycle, it is almost exclusively the program type that matters for program effectiveness. While direct employment programs in the public sector appear detrimental, wage subsidies and "Services and Sanctions" can be effective in increasing participants' employment probability.
http://www.tinbergen.nl/cost/london/kluve.pdf
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jochen Kluve is Professor of Empirical Labor Economics at the School of Business and Economics, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, and Head of the Berlin Office of RWI.

Saturday, March 3, 2012

ECB Finally Acts, Saves Banks not People

€500 Billion Loaned to Banks - Draghi Overlooks Real Economy
At the beginning of March, the ECB finally acted to address the current financial and economic situation via expansionary monetary means. Europe’s central bank issued 500 Billion in loans.

At the same time, Mario Draghi stated publicly his intention that not only was the use of monetary powers to foment economic growth, reinforce Europe’s recovery, create jobs out of the question, but that Europe’s 27 member nations not use their sovereign fiscal powers to do so either.
Central Bank Independence: Role of the Central Bank
While I am a reluctant believer in the in the independence of the central bank, it must be said that central bank independence swings both ways. The role of the central bank is purely to provide the best monetary policy possible for the economy which the central bank serves. This is the reason that most central banks have policy independence.

In Europe, the ECB’s role of is even narrower: It’s primary role is to ensure price stability. While I do not agree with this narrow focus, Draghi should understand that politics is not in his job description. Involvement in the political debates from which fiscal policy emerges will never be part of the ECB director’s job. Central bank independence means the strict separation of the monetary policy from the political debate. If  Draghi  cannot manage that, then he should resign.

What’s Wrong with Bailouts?
To boil it down to two words, Moral Hazard. While we do need to keep banks afloat, if only to keep the entire European economy from disintegrating,  we should not do it by giving away free money and allowing the failed bankers to retain their posts. Both Hayek and Smith would agree that this will just lead to further disasters down the road. Rather bailout funds should come with strings attached. strings such as corporate governance standards and a partial public-sector stake in several of the economy's key strategic banks and firms. 

On the other hand, while we are busy worrying about the banks we are ignoring the broken part of the real economy. This is a capital mistake because we worry ostensibly about the banks because they affect the real economy. Its in the real economy that job are held or lost. Its in the real economy that tangible goods and services are produced or not. If we are going to use monetary action to save one sector, we should use it to save more than one sector. 

What we Need
While monetary expansion in the Eurozone was long overdue, more attention needs to be played to the real economy where jobs and production of tangible goods and services takes place. At the same time, banks who receive public support, should get it with strings attached. Higher supervisory standards, better risk prudence (in terms of both loans and portfolio), public stake, and the dismissal of incompetent managers are good strings to start with. Otherwise, we have printed the banks some free money and will end up compelled to do it again in two-year's time.
-----------------------------------------------------------
Max Berre is an economist at the EDHEC-Risk Institute (Ecole Des Hautes Etudes Commerciales du Nord) who has worked as a sovereign debt expert at the Inter-American Development Bank in Washington and has taught financial economics at Maastricht University in the Netherlands.

Thursday, March 1, 2012

Europe: The Story Doesn't Fit the Facts Says Krugman


Krugman Rejects both PIIGS Deficit Story and "Unstable Welfare State" Story

This week, NY Times Economics Writer Paul Krugman rejected the prevailing myths about the Eurozone crisis brewing on both sides of the Atlantic. 

The Republican Story
The idea that Europe is in trouble because of it welfare state is in fact in vogue among the American right, as well as in many economic faculties across the US. For some time now, European welfare policies have been seen as a disaster waiting to happen by both the American right and the American center. Preposterous as it may sound, the idea is that by helping the poor, we are all made worse off.

Unfortunately, this story has never been quite true, either in the European or in the global contexts. For starters, the welfare states in Scandinavia are still in one piece. Furthermore, the countries now in trouble spent less of the GDP on their social systems than their northern -and more economically secure- neighbors.

The German Story 
The German story is one of how years of fiscal irresponsibility lead to the crisis that we are in now. While it might be true for Greece, it doesn't say much about the rest of southern Europe. Tellingly, this story does not hold true for Spain, Portugal or Ireland. Accordingly, the term "PIIGS" has been replaced in both European and American media by a more specific focus on Greece.

"What does ail Europe? The truth is that the story is mostly monetary"
According to Krugman, the root of Europe's economic troubles lies in the construction of a common currency without getting the underlying economic institutions right. Add to the that the steadfast insistence on austerity, despite both theory and practice being very clear about it being a failed policy for debtor nations (those who have doubts, google the words "IMF" and "austerity"). On top of that, the German refusal to change course on the ECB's monetary policy essentially means that viable monetary policy responses to Europe economic troubles. Of course none of this looks good to any traders or banks holding European assets, who at this point would rather just press the sell button on their screens and move on to greener pastures. 

What do we Need?
The response is plain and simple. We either need a more serious and responsible monetary policy for Europe immediately, or else we are in a lot of trouble (IMF style austerity, followed by rioting, followed by 10 years of lost growth.) 

At this point, "a more serious and responsible monetary policy" would involve both credit policy and a larger money supply. As annoying as it sounds that we will have a bit of inflation and that the ECB will help pick the winners for a time, it is better than half of Europe burning, which is what might just end up happening.

Monday, February 13, 2012

Greek Crisis: Shock Doctrine Comes to Europe

Brussels Praises While Athens Burns
On February 7th, 2012, the BBC reported that the troika was finalizing the deal with Greece.  What we must really ask is, what does this deal consist of, and will it help resolve Greece’s economic problems. In other words, is this deal right for Greece and for Europe?

Shock Doctrine
In 2008, Canadian Economist Naomi Klein published an account of the international rise of the neoliberal economy. The story she tells in one whereby neoliberal economic principles arise in country after country in the aftermath of a crisis or shock. These crises have been both of the economic variety and of the more conventional sort, such as earthquakes, hurricanes, tsunamis, or even wars and military shocks.
The narrative is one of the overnight imposition of austerity, privatization, and cuts in wages and benefits via the circumvention of democratic means. This is ostensibly done as a form of crisis-response. As Klein tracks the imposition of these polices through crisis after crisis, one facet becomes clear, the details of the crisis itself do not seem to matter.

"Blaming the Locals"
This phenomenon as a response to the failure of neoliberal policies in country after country to create growth, improve people’s lives, or even restore pre-crisis normality. Essentially, proponents draw on Samuel Huntington-style arguments to explain the failure of the neoliberal policy changes. In other words, the narrative that emerges is one saying “it’s not that privatization and wage cuts are bad policy, it’s that the people in this country do not have sufficient work ethic and/or entrepreneurial spirit”.

The Greek Crisis
One thing about the crisis has become clear, the response to the crisis has become about austerity. The BBC reports that Greek austerity cuts include:
  • 15,000 public-sector job cuts 
  • liberalization of labor laws  
  • lowering the minimum wage by 20% from 751 euros a month to 600 euros

As an economist, it worth noting that while lowering the minimum wage and making it easier to fire people will certainly increase poverty and unemployment, it is hard to see what upside this would bring. Within the economics profession, there is no consensus that these measure would in any way have a positive outcome. 

Not surprisingly, the Greek public does not accept the economic suffering, and has taken to the streets, giving Athens its worse riot in years. 45 building have been burned so far according the BBC. Sadly, the BBC was more interested in covering the austerity deal than the resulting protests and riots.

As for fairy tales about improving competitiveness and “expansionary austerity”, this is the same thing that IMF experts told Argentina. How did things work out then? Sadly, there will always believe that “That is South America, such things will never happen here” Last year, Europeans believed that. In fact, the plain and simple truth that austerity leads to violence. If we can solve a crisis without it, then we should. What we shouldn’t do is allow ourselves to be swayed by phony doomsday arguments.